What is your first memory of unhappiness?

Yesterday, Martyn was talking about happiness. Today, I remember that I’m asking myself questions so as to populate my R.A.Q. page. And in that hazy place I call my mind comes a memory of a story by my friend Tom Saunders. The story, “Aerobatics,” is found in his brilliant collection, Brother, What Strange Place Is This?

In the story a father is talking to his daughter and he recalls the moment, when he was nine years old, that he discovered sadness. The father is speaking:

…one day I came home from school and found my mother sitting at the kitchen table crying. Breaking her heart. Tears running fown her cheeks. Hiding her face from me, twisting away when I asked her what the matter was…

…What I mean is that the second before I came in the foor I was happy, and then suddenly I was landed with this knowledge about my mother I’d never be without. I wasn’t prepared for what I saw. For the uncertainty of it. Do you understand? I wasn’t prepared for a world where that sort of sadness was possible.

I’m trying to think about my first memory of unhappiness. I’m trying to remember when it was that I could first articulate that unhappiness existed in the world. When I remember I’ll answer the question.

Meanwhile - what is your first memory of unhappiness? How has that first experience of unhappiness marked your life? Has it come back since? Have you since used it, somehow? Articulated it?

UPDATE: I’ve thought a little more about my answer. Here it is: This is a very hard question to answer. I’m thinking that unhappiness in early childhood may exist more as a state of fear than anything else. Fear, I guess, results in uncertainty vulnerability, and I guess they are also attributes of unhappiness. I can’t think of any specific examples, apart from arguments in the home, my strict ballet teacher, my shadow, dark rooms. I was very scared of the dark and always had to sleep with the light on.

  

11 Responses to What is your first memory of unhappiness? »»


Comments

  1. Comment by Nabeel | 2006/05/05 at 19:31:04Quote

    missing my mom .. i really missed my mom one day .. and i was restless and didn’t know what to do ..
    she was away for a couple of days .. she has been away many times .. but that day I just missed her and was unhappy not to have her. That’s the earliest memory ..

  2. Comment by kathryn | 2006/05/05 at 23:44:59Quote

    How old were you at the time, Nabeel? This is interesting - unhappiness as an experience of loss and longing. Or, maybe, the experience of change from one state (with mother) to another (without mother).

  3. tom
    Comment by tom | 2006/05/08 at 01:37:53Quote

    My first solid memory (I only have vague recollections previous to it) was also my first unhappy memory. I chipped a bone in my left arm when I was four when I (fool) refused to get out of someone’s soapbox cart and they pushed me out sideways on to a concrete road. It hurt a lot. But I didn’t cry. I was a “brave boy.” Ha-ha. But unhappy as far as anguished about the world came when I had a series of very frightening nightmares a year or two later. I can’t remember what they were about now, but at the time they terrified me. It got so bad the doctor sent me to have my brain checked out on an electroencephalograph. I have the rare honour of being certified sane at a very young age!

  4. Comment by kathryn | 2006/05/08 at 12:18:06Quote

    Interesting, Tom, that anguish about the world first appeared as terror. A kind of inarticulate terror. I wonder what the cause of those nightmares were? The earliest nightmare I remember was when I was five or six or seven - well, it was sort of a waking nightmare - I saw my cat, Jackson, appear in the corner of the bedroom in the night and then multiply so that there were many Jacksons descending down upon me as I lay in bed. As I remember it - the next day I found Jackson dead. I’ve always considered that dream predictive, but now I believe that I’ve distorted the memory and what must have happened was that I found Jackson first and then had the scary nightmare vision thing. That’s the scariest memory in my life - but as far as anguish about the world, I still can’t think of a precise memory of my first articulation of it. I have a feeling that it must have come during my teens and not childhood at all. Apart from a great fear of the dark, my childhood seems to have been very very secure and happy.

  5. tom
    Comment by tom | 2006/05/08 at 12:38:59Quote

    No idea what caused the nightmares. All I can remember was the feeling of not being able to escape from something. My childhood was otherwise very happy. Nowadays my dreams are nearly always nice. It’s when I wake up I get terrified.

  6. Comment by kathryn | 2006/05/09 at 09:56:05Quote

    Ha-ha! That’s funny, Tom. My dreams often reflect the terror in my waking life - whether it’s personal or global - the fear is there and, like in your childhood dreams, I’m always running - through strange labyrinthine spaces - from something or someone.

  7. tom
    Comment by tom | 2006/05/09 at 12:18:36Quote

    We’re a right old pair.

    Jackson’s well out of it. Poor thing.

  8. Comment by Nabeel | 2006/05/11 at 20:44:18Quote

    I don’t know how old .. aaa .. I think 10 or 11 years old ..

  9. Comment by kathryn | 2006/05/13 at 23:05:05Quote

    Hi Nabeel - thanks for answering. A sense of longing at 10 or 11, huh. Memories at that age do seem to be more emotionally articulate.

  10. Comment by Steve Kane | 2006/05/21 at 01:18:16Quote

    Frankly, for as long as I can remember I’ve always been a miserable bastard.

  11. Comment by kathryn | 2006/05/21 at 02:21:22Quote

    I’ve always found the miserable bastards to be most interesting…


Leave a Reply »»

Quote selected text